Chapter Seven The Debate by D.X. Machina

2163 AD
૨૧૨૫ MA

“This is it, Jimmy,” Elaine Ridgemont said, waving her arms for emphasis. “This is the fuck-up I’ve been waiting for.”

Her husband nodded, as he sipped his coffee and read through sports scores. He was aware of the fallout from Lennox McClure’s story; it had landed like a lightning bolt in the middle of the world’s consciousness, and it had been the dominant story for three days. But he was much more interested in the scores of the DC United match; he was the grandson of a Senator, but Elaine was much more like his grandpa than he ever had been.

“Not that I blame them entirely,” Elaine mused, as she scrolled through her own newsfeed. “Can understand why they wanted to sit on this, but the public, bless their hearts, are not going to see it that way. And that can’t help but help those of us who’ve been trying to slow this headlong rush to one world government. Especially if we play up the fact that they didn’t trust the people to keep their heads.”

“The people haven’t been keeping their heads,” James replied. “Not exactly. There were riots in Jerusalem, you know.”

“Oh, I know. And demonstrations in New York City, and Brasilia, and London, and Tokyo, and Beijing…the people are mad. But so far, they’ve stopped short of riots. Well, other than Jerusalem, of course. And Mumbai.”

“Floor session today should be entertaining.”

“Oh, yes it should,” Elaine said, with a grin; she’d been in contact with the minority leader. They were going to wait a few days before they introduced the vote of no confidence. Let the majority dangle. They already had enough votes to bring the House of Humanity down, for the first time in its history; only question was whether they’d push for Lî to resign as well.

That said, she was starting to think they were better off waiting on Lî. He was well-respected, and his interview with McClure and his address to humanity had been, if not well-received, at least not received with open hostility. He had apologized, and explained why Earth’s leaders had done what they did; he could repair some of the damage. He was skilled, no doubt. If they went after him directly, they’d risk blowback. Better to whittle away at him over time, and hurt him enough that he would lose in ’67.

“So are you going to run for Secretary-General again?” Jimmy asked.

“Probably. But first things first…I’ve been talking to your grandfather. I think it’s time the Republicans took back the White House.”

“President? Interesting.”

“I know you’ve always wanted to be First Gentleman. And Thornton is going to have a hard time winning with this weighing him down. Pretty much every incumbent will.”

“You know what surprises me?” Jimmy said. “People are a lot angrier at our governments than the Titans.”

“Oh, that’s not surprising,” Elaine said. “The Titans are there. We’re here. Long as they don’t bother Earth, most people don’t honestly care what happens to the humans in the Empire. Always been that way, always will be, I’m afraid; it’s why people traded with South Africa during Apartheid, or Saudi Arabia when they were oppressing women, or Mandé during the West African War. That’s someone else’s problem. I want my gold, or oil, or what have you.”

“Still, they’ve lied.”

“Not to our governments, which is why people are right to be angry with them. Our governments could have told us whenever they wanted to. They’ve known since the first. Not the fault of the Titans that they didn’t want to shout their worst traits to the world. Fault of our leaders that they heard them, and didn’t share them.”

“I suppose. So what do you advocate? End relations with them?”

“No, no,” Elaine said, with a smile. “They are providing defense. And the article about what the Insectoids did to that one colony…well, we do not want that happening here, and we’re not ready to prevent it, yet. But that doesn’t mean we’re going to be meek. Not anymore. After all,” she said, “we are not pets.”

* * *

“It’s easy to pretend that what’s happening in the Empire doesn’t matter. The Titans keep humans as pets, but so what? Depending on who exactly is keeping me as a pet, it might not be so bad, right?”

The audience laughed as Sam Baxter waggled his eyebrows suggestively. “Right? But you wouldn’t be saying that if someone was keeping you in a cage, and dragging you out to do tricks for them, now would you?”

Baxter hosted perhaps the most influential political talk show in North America, one that blended satire, comedy, and commentary. The format was hardly new – shows like his had been in existence since “The Daily Show” back in the 20th century. But like many a great artist before him, Baxter took the format and made it his own. He was immensely popular, and one of the few talk show hosts left that most everyone knew and followed.

“See, I come out here every night, and I act like a clown, and then I get to go home and have dinner, maybe go out with my wife, maybe go to bed early. If I ever get tired of the routine, I can quit and do something else, though of course, I’m not qualified for anything else, and my wife would not be happy, but what’s she gonna do? She doesn’t own me,” Sam said, as his director lowered the studio lights twenty percent, and turned the spotlight up. “But what if she did? What if she could force me to come out here and act like a goofball, and keep me from eating if she didn’t like it? What if she could manhandle me into a cage ‘for my own protection’ and not give two shits about whether I liked it? What if she didn’t see me as a person, but as a little cocker spaniel, a parrot, a cat? Even if she was nice, well, she’d still be telling me what to do, every step of the way. Now, imagine she’s the size of a skyscraper, and you tell me how I fight back.”

Baxter paused briefly – just briefly – for effect. “Now, we’ve joked a lot about how Titan women all have triple-Q bras, and Titan men…well, let’s just say I’m not going to compare things with them at a urinal. And that’s all well and good, some of them are attractive, hooray. But I don’t care how pretty you are, owning another person is sick and wrong and evil. And guess what? It’s just dumb luck that I get to tell you that. Because I guarantee you, somewhere in the Empire there’s a human who’s ten times as funny as I am, who is right now, as we speak, doing some sort of routine to entertain their master in hopes that they’ll get another fucking bit of human chow or a better litter box, and if you think that doesn’t affect you, that just affects them, well, stay the fuck away from me and my family, because you’re the type of person who thinks a disease isn’t a big deal unless you have it. Every human being in the Empire has a disease, ladies and gentlemen, and whether it spreads here or not, they’re suffering, and if you have a shred of decency, you’re suffering with them. We’ll be right back.”

The crowd roared in affirmation; Baxter leaned back and sighed. He really didn’t like getting serious. He was a comedian first. But in the few days since the news had broken, the discussion had been about how this affected Earth. Well, fuck Earth. Not literally, he liked it here, but Earth was fine right now. He didn’t have to see the people in the Empire to know how much this sucked for them. He had his imagination. And while he didn’t know how to start fighting this, he knew enough to know that people had to start worrying about the people who were actually suffering.

His producer waived her hand, and Baxter sat forward. “All right,” he said, “Welcome back to The Recap; my guest tonight is the journalist who broke the story, welcome back to the show, Lennox McClure.”

* * *

“We have faced colonizers before,” the African MP for Dakar said. “We know what they want. They will take our land, they will take our wealth, they will take our very dignity. I have said from the beginning that they represent a threat, that they cannot be trusted. The leaders of this government have demanded secrecy. But to what end? I told the distinguished First Minister that I did not trust them, and he said to be patient. He did not trust you, my friends. I do.”

Amadou Touré sat down, and folded his arms, staring daggers at the First Minister. Filfi Adjaye chuckled and shook his head as Touré’s partisans jeered; he knew better than to engage him directly. Instead, he nodded to a man sitting in his row, rather inexperienced to be serving in the cabinet – well, inexperienced in the parliament.

“The Minister of Space Affairs, the member from Harare South, Mr. Marechera,” the chairwoman said, as Tatenda rose to his feet.

He was still not sure what had possessed him to go into politics after retiring from the JTSA. It wasn’t a natural fit. He’d had offers to teach from basically every university on the planet, he could have worked with Mukta Chandrasekhar in R&D, he could have done almost anything. Instead, he’d accidentally listened to Adjaye, and found himself as an MPA candidate for office, and now, as a cabinet minister. It seemed ridiculous.

Then again, while Marechera was a man of science, he was also a man who had lived through a very near brush with death; a series of close calls had allowed him and his crew to survive the day. He didn’t know if fate guided humans through their lives, but he couldn’t rule it out, and…well, somebody had to respond to Touré. It might as well be him.

“We are very familiar with the colonizers. Indeed, for many of us, the memory is fresh.” That brought jeers from much of the hall; Touré was a better man than the first Amadou Touré, and a much better man than Daoud Touré, but he was still here because his grandfather had run roughshod over western Africa. Mandé was a far more recent colonial power than France or England, and few Africans had forgotten it.

Tatenda smiled, as the room quieted, and Amadou Touré glowered at him. “The member from Dakar is correct in what colonizers want, of course. They do want wealth. They do want land. They do want dignity. So let us look at what the Titan Empire has taken from Earth. Have they stolen our wealth? Far from it. Historically, they blocked our planet off when it appeared that our wealth might be taken, our culture might be impacted. Today, they share a station they built with us, and allow us free passage in their territories. Do they want our land? They could take Earth, tomorrow, but they have not. They have agreed that Mars and all the worlds orbiting Jupiter are ours. Yes, they dispute Saturn and the outer solar system, but to be fair to them, they reached those lands first. A people that enters an unclaimed land may claim it; that is a fact of international law. By our own history and laws, the outer part of our solar system is theirs; indeed, they could have pursued a claim to Mars or Europa or Ganymede had they wished – even Ceres. I was not, after all, the first person to set foot there; only the first human.”

He looked down, and looked up. “Now, our dignity – yes, the member is right – they have taken it from us, for generations upon generations. Not from Earth – they have left us alone, for the most part, albeit with some troubling and horrible exceptions – but our fellow humans, those who live on Avalon, and especially those who live in the wider Empire – their dignity has been stolen from them. They have been denied the right to self-determination, the right to liberty, even the right to call themselves what they are – people.”

Tatenda looked over the room. “And yet, while the Empire has failed humanity, there are many, many Imperial citizens who have not. I was almost killed by a Titan. I was saved by many Titans, working together across several worlds and on ships in the depth of space. Titans who recognize what, yes, they always should have – that we are people. Not pets. People. These people are winning the day. They are working – too slowly! – to grant our siblings the dignity they deserve. And when they do that, and I believe they will, then what will they have taken from us? Time, perhaps – but none can alter time. We can only repair our mistakes and go on together.

“If the Titans were the colonialists that my friend from Dakar suggests, this would not be the case. Ask any general, any admiral, they will tell you the same – the Titans could easily take Earth. Every one of us could be made into a pet. Our natural resources could be carved up. Our planet and solar system could be theirs. It would take them days. Perhaps hours. We are not ready to fight them, and even if we were…they command an Empire. We command a planet – sometimes.” Marechera looked around. “They are not colonialists. Were they, they would have taken our freedom already. I do not ask my fellow members to forgive the unforgivable. But I do ask you not to fear that which is not in evidence.”

“And what, Mr. Minister, do you propose we do if they do not free our fellow humans?” Touré said, rising to his feet. “What should we do in that event? Simply accept it?”

“Of course not,” Tatenda said. “But let us get to that point first.”

“Your government still conspired to hide the truth.”

Tatenda smiled. “And yet you were in that meeting, were you not, Mr. Touré? The one where you were told about humans being held as pets? You did not rush forward to share the information with the world. Why not?”

Marechera continued to smile; Adjaye had told him exactly why not, but it was hardly something Touré could admit. All he could do is say, “I deferred to the First Minister’s judgment.”

“So you did. You would not have done so if you did not see at least some wisdom in it. Do not mistake me – I am glad this has come out. We should know the truth about the Titans, the good and the bad. And I do think, in retrospect, the information should have been shared. It was wrong not to. But do not pretend that the First Minister was foolish and wrong, when you agreed with him at the time. If he was foolish and wrong…I do apologize, but to say more would put me in violation of the rules against slandering a member of the body, and I would not do that.”

The chamber laughed at that, as Tatenda sat back down. Adjaye looked over at him, eyes twinkling. Marechera had shut down the loudest voice in the opposition, and done it ably. Hopefully, this would start to calm people’s fears. Adjaye made a mental note to talk to Tatenda; he knew the MPA would need a new leader going into the next elections. He wondered if maybe, just maybe, that leader was a relative newcomer to the parliament.

* * *

“Sam, you know I’d tell you if this was corruption or evil, but I don’t see it. As far as I can tell, the governments are telling the truth – they were worried about panicking people. Now, they were way, way, way offsides, but it was incompetence, not evil. They should have trusted us. They didn’t.”

“You’ve gotta admit, I don’t always trust us, we’re pretty stupid,” Sam Baxter said, drawing a laugh from the crowd.

“Well, it would help if people would stop rioting. That’s just proving their point,” Lennox said, wearily. He knew he wasn’t bringing his top game here, but he was exhausted. It had been a long 80 hours, and the fact that the riots had killed six people…well, he felt guilt over those six, even knowing that he’d done the right thing. They might have been alive if he had been willing to spike the story.

He didn’t regret it. But he lamented it.

“It is, Lennox, that’s stupid and wrong and damn it, if we’re not dumb animals, we should act like it. Now, you’ve said you know you’ve just got a snippet. You know there’s much more to the story. What’s next?”

“I’m working with the Aenur Foundation to get interviews with humans held as pets. For now, they’re going to be by video chat, but not forever; long-term, I intend to go to the Empire and see their lives for myself.”

“Dangerous.”

“It is, I suppose, but I’ve told you what they’re facing there; the least I can do is go cover the story. Go share their troubles. Not saying it doesn’t terrify me….”

“I bet. That’s why I sit here and complain for a living.”

“You’re smart,” Lennox chuckled. “Until then, I’m happy to say that Buzzfeed has been able to begin following the Empire’s main news channels; while they’re hardly unbiased, we’re now able to share much more information coming in unfiltered than ever before. And we’re going to be sharing that information as we move forward, starting with next month’s vote on Azatlia; it’s entirely possible that within a month, there will be a part of the Empire where humans are recognized as people. That is a hopeful sign.”

“Let’s hope it’s just the beginning,” Baxter said, shaking Lennox’s hand.

* * *

“I don’t see a way around it,” Forna Qorni said, shaking her head. “We’re going to have to raise the room-and-board credit ten percent in High Density-Alpha worlds, and eight percent in High Density-Beth, and if we don’t want the rural voters to scream, we’re gonna have to raise the baseline by five percent. That’s gonna blow a hole in the budget, and then some, but if we don’t do it, we’re at serious risk of losing supply.”

Zeramblin nodded. “All right. Threaten Tradition – tell them that we’re going forward, and that honestly, if they bolt, the alternatives are to call snap elections or work with Aspire, who would be more than happy to support us if we raised the baseline by seven. It’ll mean a tax increase, but I think we can manage to keep it sane if we keep the education funding increase down to two percent, which will be tight for them, but let’s be honest, we’ve been pushing education hard the last ten years, and room-and-board has suffered for it; time to flip the script.”

“I agree,” Qorni said. “And I’ll remind Tradition that Loona Armac would be happy to raise taxes to cover the whole thing.”

“Do that, because it’s true,” Zeramblin said. His pad buzzed.

“Mr. Floor Leader, Ambassador Martin is here for your meeting.”

“Thanks, Roda. We’re just wrapping up. Actually,” he said, considering for a moment, “Forna, you stay for a second. No reason you shouldn’t be here for this. Roda, send the Ambassador in…give us five minutes.”

“Yes, Mr. Floor Leader,” the receptionist replied.

“Really, Mr. Floor Leader, I…would rather not,” Qorni said.

“Get over it,” Zeramblin said. “You admitted just the other day that Earth was going to have to be recognized. Well, that means their Ambassador is no different than Ambassador Keyor.”

“Still…I would rather wait until we’ve managed to kill the human emancipation issue.”

“And I’d like to have the build of a veeball defender, but we can’t all have everything we want. Forna, if you’re gonna have my job someday, that means you have to understand what you can and can’t control. If an Ambassador representing ten billion people asks for a meeting, you meet with them.”

“’People.’”

“People, Forna. You and I both know that nothing’s stopping that ship. What happens to the humans in the Empire is still up for debate, but the humans on Earth are going to be seen as people, no way to block that.”

“That will make it very hard….” Qorni began, but the door buzzed, and opened.

“Ambassador Martin,” Zeramblin said, standing up. “Good to see you again.”

“Likewise. You remember my assistant, Sev Tralo?”

“Of course,” Zeramblin said, to the Titan who was carrying the diminutive Terran Ambassador. “Good to see you again, Mr. Tralo.”

“And you, Mr. Floor Leader,” the man said, setting Robyn on the desk of the Floor Leader; he quickly placed a chair for her, and then said, “I will be outside if you need me, Ambassador.”

“Thank you, Sev. Mr. Floor Leader, will you be so kind as to alert Sev when we’re done?”

“Of course, Ambassador,” Zeramblin said, reaching out a finger to shake Martin’s hand. “And tell Roda that I said you should get the blue-key treatment. She’ll know what that means.”

“Thank you, Mr. Floor Leader,” Sev said, quickly taking his leave.

“Now, I don’t believe we’ve met, but you’re the Deputy Floor Leader, Rep. Qorni, correct? Robyn Martin, it’s nice to meet you.”

Qorni was nonplussed; she had made a habit of not treating humans as people, even when it would do no harm. She knew that even giving the slightest indication that she recognized their sentience would undermine the argument that they weren’t sentient. Still, the Floor Leader was right – Earth was legally recognized as an independent entity. And this was their duly recognized ambassador. Protocol dictated she show respect. And there wasn’t a camera crew in the room.

“It’s…a pleasure to meet you, Ambassador,” Qorni finally said, though she did not reach out a finger.

Martin gave her a slight smirk, and turned back to Zeramblin. She did not return to her seat.

“Mr. Floor Leader, thank you for meeting with me. I’m afraid I’m not here on a friendly visit.”

“I expect not,” Zeramblin said. “How are your people taking it?”

“Well enough, as far as it goes. Riots in two cities, massive protests in most other major ones, but so far, only muted calls to kick Ambassador Bass off the planet. Still, my governments have asked me to formally reiterate our objection to the status of humans in the Empire; we continue to condemn their treatment in the most stringent terms, and demand an immediate end to their being held as property.”

“I imagine this is a bit more pointed now,” Zeramblin said.

“As I told Ambassador Bass over one of your years ago, God help us all if this comes out. Well, it’s come out. I have no idea how this will shape up, but I expect the House of Humanity to call new elections, and the government that replaces them will be less receptive than the current one.”

“So what?”

Zeramblin and Martin both turned to Qorni, who was sitting with her arms folded.

“I beg your pardon, representative?”

“So what? What are you going to do if we don’t change? You can’t defend yourselves, you need us to keep the Insectoids off your world. You want us to pull the Gyfjon and Minatar out of the system, leave Titan Station? It will save us lots of money. We could use it to help fill our budget deficit.”

Martin shook her head. “Rep. Qorni, you should probably talk to the Floor Leader about diplomatic customs; while our phrasing is a bit different, both Earth and the Empire have traditionally used formal language in our discussions.”

“You little…how dare you come into this office and lecture me about….”

“Forna, this is my office, and you are speaking to the Ambassador from Earth,” Zeramblin said, coolly. “To use the proper phrasing, your conduct is deeply abhorrent, and continuing such conduct would make you a detriment.”

Qorni blinked; Zeramblin had used the formal language of Imperial politics. Translated, he had said bluntly that if she didn’t shut her fucking mouth, he would fire her for conduct.

It would trigger a rift in the caucus, might bring down the government. But the truth is that if he fired her for insulting an ambassador, even a human one….

“I apologize,” Qorni said. “However, I might remind the ambassador that the Empire has taken a pro-active stance in defending Earth, and we would regret if that were to change.”

“See? Now that’s a diplomatic threat properly delivered,” Martin said, with a sardonic smile. “I would simply remind the Representative that Titan Station does not just protect Earth, but Azatlia and Vorsha as well, and by extension the bordering Seretana province; I don’t think you would want to be angering distant-coreward constituencies given the razor-thin majority your government has, but that is of course your government’s prerogative. At any rate, the governments of Earth recognize that we are both in your peoples’ debt and rightly aggrieved by your peoples’ treatment of the children of Earth who live under your government’s rule. It is because we understand both to be true that we are here.”

“So you aren’t going to kick us out of Sol Earth,” Qorni said.

“Representative, I am a human. We have faced down extinction more than once; we are not going to kick you out of Sol Earth because we believe your government may yet listen to reason, and may yet decide to do the right thing, and free our fellow humans. But if the day should come when we cannot believe that, if the day should come that your government should decide, once and for all, that humans cannot ever be your equals…well, at that point, regrettably, we would have no choice but to view your government as a hostile entity, and take what steps are necessary to defend ourselves and others.”

“You would fight us? We’d destroy you in twenty seconds,” Qorni retorted.

“Perhaps,” Martin said. “But as I said, we believe it need not come to that. We would much rather be your ally then enemy, and I believe the converse is true. But you know how we live; time for us is not as long as time for you. We cannot wait forever, and we will not wait forever. We ask simply that you understand this.”

“We do, Ambassador,” Zeramblin said. “Please reiterate to your governments that we are continuing to study the matter, and hope to bring our discussion to a close within the next two Titan years. I recognize that is thirteen of yours, but….”

“Mr. Floor Leader!”

“Representative,” Zeramblin said, “I will speak with you after the Ambassador leaves. As I was saying, it will be thirteen of your years, maybe less, but no more, at least, such is our hope.”

“I will communicate that to my governments. And as I have said before, Mr. Floor Leader, I recognize that this is a significant change in a short time; we do appreciate your continued discussion, and your continued support of Earth. And while we must assert our independence and willingness to defend our fellow humans…..”

“Were I in your shoes, Ambassador Martin, I could do no different; understand that we recognize precisely why Earth is aggrieved, and exactly what a failure to change the status of humans in the Empire could lead to.”

“Thank you, Mr. Floor Leader. I shall. You may call in my assistant.”

Five minutes later, Qorni stared daggers at Zeramblin in the otherwise-empty office.

“Tell me,” Zeramblin finally said, after studiously ignoring her, “do you think she was bluffing about fighting us?”

That’s what you ask me?” Qorni fairly shouted.

“Yes,” Zeramblin replied. “That’s what I ask you. Do you think she was bluffing?”

“Obviously.”

“Well, you’re wrong,” Zeramblin said. “She isn’t. We have pretty good intelligence on Earth now. Defense spending on the planet had been dropping like a rock for twenty years. It’s soaring now, and based around weapons that would work in space. Nothing for us to fear, not yet, but then, twenty years ago they hadn’t gone past their moon. You think twenty years from now they won’t be willing to fight us, on their home turf? And even if they lose – you think they won’t draw blood?”

“They wouldn’t dare. The Insectoids….”

“…would rout them. I know. But then they’d rout us.”

“So we should prepare for war, then,” Qorni said. Zeramblin laughed.

“Is that what you get out of this? No, Forna. Fighting a completely avoidable war is a stupid idea, always. What happens if we win? We get to occupy Earth? Think they’ll just take it in stride, greet us as their new overlords with no worries? Think the public will enjoy watching the military slaughter humans, or worse, the blowback when the humans kill one of our soldiers? Don’t misunderstand – they don’t want war. But they can’t let this stand. Think how we’d feel if the Drazari owned Titans, how we’d feel if the Ler kept us as slaves. They’re going to push us diplomatically, but if we don’t do something, they’re going to eventually push us militarily.”

“We can’t just free humans. We’ve been over this….”

“That’s fine, and all. But tell me – if you were her, what would you have said different than she did?”

“I would have been more sensible than to threaten. Stupid human….”

“You were the bellicose one, Forna. You were the one who invited the threats. You were the one who threatened to pull the CAP on Sol Earth, just because they were upset with us. The only reason I haven’t demanded your resignation is that I know it would bring down the government, and what’s more, there’s a fifty-fifty chance Loona Armac would be forming the next one. She said, flatly, that Earth despises how we treat humans, and while they’re willing to be patient, they aren’t gonna be so forever. Well, frak, that’s just logic. Not a sentient species in the universe would see it different.”

“So you’re going to appease them, then?”

“No, but I gorram know what the cost of opposing emancipation will be. Not just in the Empire, but in the Orion Arm.”

“You’re leaning toward it, aren’t you?”

“I am undecided, Forna, and if you want to ensure that Loona Armac is the one to call the question, you take that and run with it. There are a lot of moving parts here, and it’s grown beyond just our parochial concerns. That doesn’t mean I support emancipation, but it does mean I’m open to the idea, and frankly, given the polls, I don’t think it will matter much if we beat it back now. The government that follows will be more pro-human, and the government that follows that will be more pro-human…it will pass eventually. The question is whether we want to keep fighting a rear-guard effort or rip the bandage off. It’s a matter of time.”

“I refuse to accept that. We can still stop it. And I will demand that you not call the question without submitting it to a vote by the cabinet.”

Zeramblin laughed. “Frak you. The statute is clear. When you’re in this seat, you let someone tell you to give up your statutory authority, and you’ll say the same thing. Now, I know calling the question without giving fair warning will lead to me being sacked, and I’m not stupid. So you can rest assured that the cabinet will know if and when I call the committee to a vote. And again, Forna, you want to put Armac in charge, you go for it, and make a play. But then, she’ll call the question the second she’s in my chair; I’m willing to wait a bit, and see how I ultimately feel when the committee’s done. You’ll bury it, but again, odds are good you won’t get the chance.”

Qorni shook her head; the bastard was right. “Mr. Floor Leader, I will continue to work with you because in the end I believe that you will do the right thing. But if you will not, then regrettably, I will view you as hostile to the conservative caucus, and I will act accordingly.”

“Told you – you wouldn’t have said anything different than Martin,” Zeramblin said. “Now, get out of here, before I decide that maybe today is a day to bring down the government after all.”

Qorni stormed out of the office, and headed for her own. No question, it was time. It would take a year or so to get everything in order, but she had to act now; Zeramblin had to be taken out, before the committee reported.

43 comments

  1. Northwest says:

    “It’s not the crime; it’s the cover-up” has been a truism of politics since Watergate. Hard to believe anyone would be surprised at humanity’s reaction to being lied to, but harder to believe that no one in-story would point out the cliche when explaining it.

  2. NightEye says:

    We have pretty good intelligence on Earth now. Defense spending on the planet had been dropping like a rock for twenty years. It’s soaring now, and based around weapons that would work in space.

    Yep, like I said before, now that the Empire as an “embassy”, ie. a spy agency, right on Earth, they have full intelligence on what humans are doing. Our communications aren’t even secure from their technology, it’s child play for them to spy on us.
    So we can’t do anything that would take them by surprise. I maintain allowing a Titan presence on Earth proper was a huge mistake.
    Titan station would have been fine for diplomatic purposes.

    • Locutus of Boar says:

      I maintain allowing a Titan presence on Earth proper was a huge mistake. Titan station would have been fine for diplomatic purposes.

      As Zeramblin noted avoiding an unnecessary war is preferable to winning one. Titans were always capable of eavesdropping on humans but for the first time they are actually listening to what’s being said and that is a good thing. Anyway, what the Earthlings do is never what scares a titan…it’s how fast the humans do it that is the scary part.

    • Nitestarr says:

      Well it could be that they are better at monitoring earth’s transmissions or at least paying closer attention. More than just a casual glance at a ‘nature preserve’. They could also place their own cloaked spy satellites with the sole aim of intelligence gathering.

      Or perhaps they employ good ole’ fashioned spy craft…Perhaps get Tig or a friend of a friend of Tig just to listen to her spill the beans on Ted…

    • Johnny Scribe says:

      “Yep, like I said before, now that the Empire as an “embassy”, ie. a spy agency, right on Earth, they have full intelligence on what humans are doing. ”

      … Pryvani paid someone to download the entire internet from millions of miles away. Titans being on the same planet is really rather irrelevant.

      • Nitestarr says:

        That was back in 2015 (ish)..Now it is 150 years later and Earth has changed radically.. Technology, military socially etc. 150 year old data is virtually useless.

        Going through the entire internet? wow imagine having to filter through all the fluff to try to gleam nuggets of useful info. Thats like Titans today trying to determine our present military capacity by looking at civil war era documents..They would need boots on the ground – hence the embassy….And that could cut the other way too ya know…

        • Johnny Scribe says:

          That’s not at all my point.

          My point isn’t that “hey Pryvani has the internet data from a century ago, therefore they already know everything!” My point is “She downloaded the goddamn internet from half a solar system away, being on the same spinning rock as said data won’t really make spying any easier”

          If the titans wanted to “listen in” being on Earth, the Moon or Titan Station won’t really change how efficient their “spying” methods are.

          in other words, the important part of what I said wasn’t “downloaded the internet” it was “from millions of miles away”

          • Locutus of Boar says:

            And if you know you can’t prevent the enemy from reading you mail you give them something you want them to read.

            In the months before D-Day Winston Churchill called this Operation Fortitude.

          • faeriehunter says:

            Uh, JohnnyScribe? I feel uncomfortable asking this given that you’re an author and I’m not, but wasn’t the “internet download” done by Gyfjon personnel during its mission to Earth to capture Eyrn? There is a little snippet in Titan: Exile chapter seventeen where Dayun Pir and Derna Tae discuss a download that they don’t want to get caught with and are getting paid for by a “she”. If so then the “internet download” wasn’t done “from millions of miles away”; the Gyfjon was still in Earth orbit at that point.

            I’m only asking because I want to make sure that I interpreted that scene correctly though, not because I think that it matters regarding the Empire having better information about Earth after Contact than before:

            Firstly, the Empire’s government will now have a much greater desire for information regarding Earth. The events of Titan: Contact and their aftermath made humans a hot topic in politics, and led to Earth and its colonies getting changed from a preserve to a sovereign region. Not to mention that it must have been embarrassing to be taken by surprise by the arrival at Saturn of a pre-warp vessel from a planet under Imperial surveillance; the Empire would want more information about Earth if only to prevent getting surprised again.

            Secondly, now that Contact has occurred the Empire no longer has to keep its distance and hide its presence. This makes gathering information through scans much easier. And now that the Empire and Earth are in regular contact it’s only to be expected that the Empire has access to Earth’s internet. The Empire will now undoubtedly have one or more AI’s busy sifting through all the data looking for topics of interest. I’m pretty sure that the various Earth governments were already doing the exact same with each other. Hell, replace ‘AI’ with ‘search algorithm’ and you can bet that it is true in real life today.

          • Nitestarr says:

            FH;

            “And now that the Empire and Earth are in regular contact it’s only to be expected that the Empire has access to Earth’s internet. ”

            That is the head scratching part..Since the empire is all mighty and powerful it would stand to reason that they always had access to Earth’s internet. That goes all the way back to the beginning of the information age. I’m guessing that they had this knowledge but dismissed it; “Ha so what a bunch of talking gerbils built a spaceship and landed on their moon! . they are still very cute”

            At this point the governments of earth realize who Los Titans are and what they are and have taken extreme measures to secure their critical military info. Probably leaking some of it intentionally

        • Ancient Relic says:

          They could secure a lot of information by not connecting the computer to the Internet, or any other network, and putting the computer in a locked room that next to nobody has access to.

          • NightEye says:

            It wouldn’t because they can access our computers remotely, no matter if they are connected to the internet or not. Or at least, I’m pretty sure that’s what Pryvani is implying when she talks about it with Darren in Exile.

          • TheSilentOne says:

            There’s a lot of suspension of disbelief that goes toward a sci-fi story, and I’m fine with that. However, accessing a physical storage medium that’s the equivalent of just a few hundreth’s of an inch across from 6 trillion+ miles (1 light year or more) or even 1.2 billion miles (the closest distance from Earth to Saturn) seems a bit beyond belief.

            Do you happen to a passage in mind for where you thought Pryvani implied this? It seems much more likely they captured satallite data, and potentially other wireless data, but neither wired data and especially not “off the grid” computer systems.

          • NightEye says:

            @TheSilentOne : Exile Chapter 62

            “A while ago, there was a data stream pirated from Earth. I’m not sure by who, exactly. This stream contained all digital information from the planet, in every language, from every nation with access to their information super highway.”
            […]
            “Well I’ll be….they didn’t even let me see this one, this is top-level stuff,” Darren looked up to Pryvani.

            “Our computer systems were able to download the encrypted files; you shouldn’t take that as an insult, our computers are far more advanced.”

            So on the one hand, it could be interpreted as there was a need for a link to the internet but on the other hand, those files were highly classified (photos of Eyrn’s parents’ spaceship) : would that be on a computer connected to the Internet ?

          • Locutus of Boar says:

            They could secure a lot of information by not connecting the computer to the Internet, or any other network, and putting the computer in a locked room that next to nobody has access to.

            There was in interesting episode of Battlestar Galactoca where the whole thing boiled down to a race between the Colonials maibtaining a secure network long enough to do their work before the Cylons could penetrate the defenses.

            Earth’s greatest defense against the titans is the volume of the internet relative to the likely volume of the system they deal with in the less population dense titan worlds. Also there is a hard speed limit on reading Earth’s internet imposed by the physical limitations of Earth’s servers. What Pryvani had done takes too much time for what they need now.

            If the titans know where to look they can probably penetrate any networked system and potentially any isolated system without serious electromagnetic shielding. The defense is not isolation but rather hiding in plain site by confusing the titans (and likely the insectoids who are listening too) with too many decoys.

          • Nitestarr says:

            Apparently anything with a electromagnetic signature is at risk…..Well there are ways to defense that..old school.. go back to pen and paper with physical file cabinets (only for crucial data and communications)..

            Vacuum tube tech could make a comeback, along with other analog systems…

          • faeriehunter says:

            So on the one hand, it could be interpreted as there was a need for a link to the internet but on the other hand, those files were highly classified (photos of Eyrn’s parents’ spaceship) : would that be on a computer connected to the Internet ?

            It’s possible that spies got their hands on those classified files (for example, I’ve heard that over the years more than one USB stick with sensitive information was lost (read: probably got stolen)) and used the internet to send them to the organization they were working for in order to get those files decrypted.

    • Soatari says:

      Embassies have always doubled as spy agencies. It’s nothing new, and I’m sure the Earth’s intelligence agencies are fully aware of the spying being done by Archavia.

      • Locutus of Boar says:

        Embassies have always doubled as spy agencies.

        While the thought of Eryn in her Tol-Bot mask sneaking around Las Vegas at night peering in windows is certainly worthy of a render I don’t think intelligence gathering by the official Archavian government is the worry. It’s the enemies dedicated to the suppression or out right destruction of Earth causing trouble by paying humans to do the dirty work for them that is the real concern.

        • Soatari says:

          Lemme rephrase; They double as surveillance posts. Passive spying, instead of active intelligence gathering.

  3. smoki1020 says:

    Qorni’s reaction to Martin’s comments are pretty poor politically. She must be smarter than that to be Solis’s associate.Just 6 deads over riots around the world! That’s a contained blowback ! Lennox however feel the heat for riots as he plays titans advocate afterward.

    • Nitestarr says:

      I don’t think he should do that given that he is a journalist..However if he is following 21st century precedents that would be entirely normal 🙂

  4. Kusanagi says:

    Excellent chapter, it was already good going into the final conversation but wow Martin brought it A completely diplomatic ‘fuck you’ to Qorni. She’s absolutely proven herself incapable of being floor leader with this chapter, she’s basically fighting to keep a potential emancipated human vote out of the empire but is willing to engage in multiple wars to do so! The conservatives have a narrow lead, support of emancipation is growing, earth achievements are happening on a regular basis. Her political career is going to die on this hill, how she expects to keep the majority with her ideas requires some insane mental gymnastics.

    Martin was excellent, well done research on her end to make Qorni look like a youtube commenter rather than a politician. Zeramblin has become one of my favorite characters, he knows these are his last days but he’s getting the absolute most out of them. He’s a slimey politician but it’s awesome to watch him use his skills for the human rights movement.

    Aside from them love the Jon Stewart the IV moments. He pretty much nailed it.

  5. Soatari says:

    And here come the slimeball politicians oozing out of the woodwork to take advantage of this discord.

  6. sketch says:

    The blow back seems pretty measured and contained for now, though I understand why people are more upset with the government than the Titans right now.

    I like Sam Baxter’s take. (I did think he was setting up an interview with Tig though given his example.) I hope when this settles that Earth might actually send aid workers to Azatlia, along with advisors from Avalon, and start taking in former pets from there and around the empire to help adjust them to personhood.

    Ambassador Martin certainly knows how to make the most of what she has to work with. The titans protect the Earth border as much for their own well-being as the humans. Humanity has the foolhardiness to face down extinction fighting, but of course it doesn’t have to be that way. I would also love to see a chapter someday of what a day in the life is like for a human ambassador in the empire. (Well that and a story when human starships are able to join a fight against the insectoids.)

  7. Nitestarr says:

    Lennox is being a bit naive here. Dropping this bombshell about the ‘friendly’ aliens and expecting no one to get hurt? Humans are nervous, panicky animals so this should be no surprise..All this on just the cursory superficial stuff, just wait until McClure gets into the real heart of the deal..

    Wonder if Titan TV (TT) will air scenes of the riots? their viewpoint should prove interesting..

    Ya know I wonder if they fortified Ambassador Bass’s compound…It is still vulnerable and subject to either terrorist or a militia type attack…real dumb if they didn’t plan ahead for that….

  8. Locutus of Boar says:

    “They wouldn’t dare. The Insectoids….”
    “…would rout them. I know. But then they’d rout us.”

    Hmmm, this is a bit of news. So the empire, even united as it is at least for now isn’t ready for the bad guys. If Earth knows this chances are its suspected on Hive Prime too. Earth just has an advantage because Martin is access to the best intelligence network in the empire.

    Zeramblin had to be taken out, before the committee reported.

    Is Zerablin inviting a palace coup d’état? Flush and eliminate his internal threats and buy Aspire’s cooporation to stay in power through the emancipation process? Whatever, it appears it all hits the fan in one Titan year.

    • Kusanagi says:

      I read that not as the Empire isn’t ready for a conflict with the Insectoids, so much as they aren’t ready for the Insectoids after a conflict with an Earth + 130 years. It’s like saying the Empire and Insectoids are equal, but an extended conflict would weaken the empire to the point where the Insectoids would have the advantage.

      • Locutus of Boar says:

        I suspect the authors having something grander in mind and are laying the groundwork bit by bit.

        I also suspect we just found the identity of one of Solis’ co-conspirators.

        And I think they intend to play out a variant of the 2102 Tol-Bot final in >I>Hybrid Only this time the re-enforcements for Gama fleet will be drawn off to deal with the Federation rebellion and possible defectors in the fleets loyal to Solis in order to intentionally leave the door open for the insectoids to take care of what the conspirators see as all the “problems” in that corner of the galaxy: Earth, Azatlia, and Avalon and the Tarsuss commercial empire.

        • faeriehunter says:

          I read “but then they’d rout us” much like Kusanagi. Eyrn said in the previous chapter that Titan Station is a significant asset, and the primary staging area for defense against the insectoids. What Rodrec is saying (in my opinion) is that a conflict with Earth 20 Archavian years from now would compromise Titan Station, creating a gap in the Empire’s defense of the region that the insectoids would be all too happy to take advantage of.

          That having been said, I think that the Empire isn’t nearly as ready for an insectoid attack as it thinks it is. The Empire hasn’t faced more than probing attacks since the Second Insectoid War, but I’m pretty sure that the insectoids recognize which way the wind is blowing now. If they don’t take Sol Earth before humans are emancipated then its defenses will skyrocket to a level befitting the homeworld of a species that are Empire citizens. For the insectoids it’s really now or never, so I expect them to mount an attack in the near future. A serious one, not a probe. And judging from previous mentions of the insectoids’ influence in the Empire’s underworld I’d say that the attack won’t just involve a fleet. Another factor is that the Empire’s military hardware appears to be aging even by their standards, probably due to insufficient government funding. But perhaps most importantly, Lorna Qorni and Jota Cesil are setting the stage for a nasty political chaos. What better time to launch a surprise attack than when your enemy is without a clear leader and crippled by internal division?

          As for Lorna being one of Solis’ co-conspirators, it’s possible but I’m not convinced. Sure, she’s adamant about humans not getting emancipated. But that does not necessarily mean that she’s going so far as to give Earth to the insectoids, sacrifice its defenders and leave the entire region vulnerable to a further insectoid incursion. Lorna just strikes me as the type who lacks the long-term vision a good leader needs. I’d say that for her, human emancipation must be stopped at all costs to prevent them from giving the Empire’s progressive parties enough votes to lead the Empire, for they’d lead the Empire into ruin. What she refuses to see is that she’s only delaying the inevitable, and that her efforts will more likely than not end up giving the progressives ammunition to denounce the conservatives with, thus backfiring on her goal.

          • Locutus of Boar says:

            Well put FH.

            But that does not necessarily mean that she’s going so far as to give Earth to the insectoids, sacrifice its defenders and leave the entire region vulnerable to a further insectoid incursion.

            Give may not be the right word. Constructing a scenario where the insectoids appear to be the gulty party starting a war that sacrafices the Empire’s most liberal colony, eliminates the liberals greatest economic support and eliminates the threat of humans ever becoming voters in the empire while giving the conservatives a rallying cause to eliminate the insectoid threat once and for all makes a lot of sense from the POV of a would be Floor Leader who wants to get a statue of herself put out on the front lawn.

          • faeriehunter says:

            Like I said, it’s possible but I’m not convinced. While that scenario would be major blow to the progressives and their effort to emancipate humans, I don’t see Lorna being callous enough to willingly sacrifice millions of titans and billions of humans for no more reason than that it’d aid the conservative cause.

          • Locutus of Boar says:

            I don’t see Lorna being callous enough to willingly sacrifice millions of titans and billions of humans

            I could see her callous enough to sacrifice the roughly 600K Titans an Azatlia that were destined to vote against her if given the chance. That’s fewer titans than were lost at Sperikos but enough to have a galvanizing effect on the empire if lost to an insectoid attack..

            As for the humans she made her views clear enough in this chapter.

          • Nitestarr says:

            Thats not just callous, its criminal and traitorous. Willing to sacrifice 600K + fellow Titan just to promote her political agenda? Even the Titan party is not willing to do that. They want a Titan racial/cultural purity to clean up from the inside letting the insectoids kill 600K of their fellow Titans would be abhorrent to them – the whiff of that would crush them in the polls

          • Locutus of Boar says:

            That’s not just callous, its criminal and traitorous.

            In other words its politics. And the deal between Qorni and the Titan Party may already be cut. Titan Party couldn’t pull it off at the ballot box directly and Qorni has decided to pull the trigger on their Plan B. The interesting thing is Zeramblin seems to sense it coming and seems to be giving Qorni the rope in hopes she will hang herself.

            “With the Titan Party providing the majority,” Loona said. “Zeramblin wouldn’t bring them in, but if the conservatives need to bring them in, Zeramblin won’t be Floor Leader, Qorni will.”

    • NightEye says:

      I still don’t understand Qorni. She doesn’t seem to be among those who truly believe humans to be animals. She simply doesn’t want her party / coalition to lose power.
      How does that translate into opposing human emancipation ?

      As Zeramblin keeps pointing out, it’s a loser no matter what : pro-human sentiment is on the rise and opposing it will push her party into irrelevance.
      And Eyrn stated that Earth joining Earth was a long way off even if we wanted it (so I assume the legislature agrees on this : it’s not even on the horizon). So again, pet humans + Avalon, that’s less than a billion humans, so less than 2% of the electorate for the Legislature.
      If that’s truly unbearable politically, Qorni has other problems than human emancipation…

      Her stubborness on this issue makes no sense to me, not from her, not unless she’s stupid and she doesn’t seem to be.

      • Kusanagi says:

        If humans in the empire are emancipated what’s to stop them from becoming citizens of the Empire? Then who would those humans vote for? Certainly NOT the conservatives. At least that’s how I see her logic. Human emancipation means the death of her party, or at least the death of her party on the grand stage.

        • synp says:

          That is Nighteye’s point. If they all get the vote, they’re still so few, so what difference does it make?

          Still, in election systems with local representatives, even a small minority can swing some important seats.

          • faeriehunter says:

            Aside from swinging contested provinces into the progressives’ favor, also remember that not everyone who can vote will indeed vote. The percentage of emancipated humans who will use their new voting ability is going to be much higher than the percentage of voting titans, many of whom won’t bother, reasoning that their vote doesn’t matter. “My vote is just one of many, it’s not going to make a difference.” “The politicians are all in cahoots anyway. They’ll make pretty promises during election time, only to later break them with backroom deals.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *