“Frankly, if you do politics, you should not be thinking about your dignity.”
—Aung San Suu Kyi
“So how did you like Mikel?”
“Ugh. Don’t start with this again, Pryvani,” Loona said. It had been a week since Pryvani had floated the idea of her running, and while Loona had to admit, she was toying with the idea…she was incredibly turned off by the people she’d talked to so far.
“So Mikel wasn’t helpful?” Pryvani asked. She’d dropped by Loona’s house unannounced, and when she heard the humans were asleep, she had insisted on sticking around until they woke up.
Of course, Pryvani was supposed to have left for Avalon two days ago, so Loona wasn’t buying the cover story. Not that Pryvani expected her to.
“Well, he didn’t hit on me like Stoel Trekaa. No, he was more interested in selling his brother’s advertising firm than explaining how I can beat Zapat. And don’t tell me, ‘But of course you can beat Zapat, dear!’ again. I know you’ve lined up donors. All the money in the world doesn’t help if I don’t have a strategy, and strategy doesn’t work if I have a piece of tuppshaka working for me.”
“That’s true,” Pryvani said with a smile.
Loona groaned. “You’ve got another one lined up? That’s the third hack this week!”
“He’s not a hack,” Pryvani said. “He’s smarter than that. I had him take a look at the numbers, and he said he’d talk to you.”
“Hmpf. What restaurant do I have to go to this time?”
“Oh, he said he’d call — ah,” said Pryvani, pulling out a data pad, “there he is now. Ammer, good to see you!”
“Pryvani, dear, a pleasure as always. Is now a good time?”
“Yes! I was just telling Loona the good news.”
“Well…’good’ might be a stretch. Put her on.”
Pryvani handed the pad over to Loona, who propped it up on her desk; she would hear this guy out, and then she was done. She couldn’t take another smooth-talking political pro who was working more for his fee than her election.
“You must be Loona Armac. Senator Tarsuss keeps telling me she thinks you have a future in politics.”
“Does she.”
“Yeah, I’m not sure. I mean, I’ve watched some of your talking head spots, and you’re quick on your feet. You did a nice job in the Freeman hearing — and that showed some political savvy that not everyone has. And the behind-the-scenes stuff you did with Darren was nice, until you let Prenn knife you in the back. You’ve done a nice job of leveraging your brand, too – you may not be getting rich, but you’re decently well-known, so that’s something.”
He looked down at some notes. “You’re pretty, you can talk in plain Archavian, which people like. And the big strikes against you aren’t that bad. The whole book controversy is a non-starter. Beat to death ten years ago, and given how Nonah’s books are selling, the public agrees. Same with you being pro-human rights — bit of a fringe position, but it’s not gonna hurt you in a district that’s 20 percent under-30 voters, especially when they’re relatively affluent as a group. I expect you’d get hit by some folks who’d try to smear you as a human-lover, but I have a feeling you can handle them. Most likely rebound against them in a socially tolerant district like Tef-West.”
Loona had stopped editing Nonah’s latest manuscript, and turned to the pad. “I didn’t catch your name.”
“Ammer Smit.”
“That’s an odd name,” Loona said.
“You’re far from the first person to tell me that. So yeah, you’ve got some talent, and your big negatives aren’t all that big given your constituency, but the thing I don’t quite trust about you, Loona Armac, is that you’re too damned idealistic.”
“What?” Loona asked.
“You’re too idealistic. Look, there’s nothing wrong with being one of them starry-eyed idealists who thinks anything is possible with enough sanctimony and moral certitude, that if you just explain things to people in the proper way that they’ll understand, but that isn’t politics. You have to be willing to compromise. To make hard choices.”
“I did. To save Darren Avery’s life.”
“Like I said, you left your back wide open that time. Not encouraging. And you’ve gotten more strident since. No, you have to be willing to not just take half a loaf, but half a crumb if that’s what works – and you have to be willing to check the crumb for poison. I don’t know if you’re willing to do that.”
Loona folded her arms. “And why should I be?”
Ammer laughed. “You don’t have to be! You can be an activist, or stay a writer. Sit back, take potshots at the government. Complain at gatherings and forums. Gather signatures for petition drives. Nothing wrong with any of that — really, I mean that, I love activists. But that’s not what a politician does.”
Loona leaned back, and said, “So I’m not supposed to have ideals?”
“Never said that. Never would,” Ammer said. “Every politician worth her salt has ideals. Some of them have the ideal that they’d like to make the Empire a better place. Some have the ideal that they’d like to make a lot of money for them and their family. But having ideals is good. It tells you why you’re doing this. If you don’t have ideals, you shouldn’t run. You just need to know that the perfect world you imagine is not attainable by mere mortals; There’s no magical, wonderful land where gok’ma trees line the street and all is perfect.”
Loona thought on this, quietly. She wasn’t sure whether she was liking this more or less than having a potential campaign manager hand her a rate card.
“So here’s a hypothetical, Loona Armac, and this will tell me everything I need to know about you. You’ve won. You’ve made it in to the House, and you’ve got a bill that’s going to give humans limited rights.”
“Why that bill?”
“Why not? Anyhow, you’ve written up this bill to allow Titans to set up trusts that can be accessed by humans, allowing them some measure of financial independence. It’s actually moving through the House, because it’s not a big change, and besides, if Titans set up the trusts, Titans are still in charge.”
“Anyhow, the majority tells you that they’ll agree to allow the bill through — if it contains language that prevents the bureaucracy from changing the status of humans from Class Two to Class One without consulting the legislature. What do you do?”
Loona leaned back. “Well…I’d need to know what language we’re talking about. Does it require simple majority? Two-thirds? Is there a sunset clause? That sort of thing.”
“All right, you do that, and now Titans for the Ethical Treatment of Humans is screaming that you’re a traitor, willing to sell out humans to pass a lousy bill that does nothing for them.”
Loona shifted. “I try not to pay attention to TETH.”
“So does everyone. But you go home and see your friend Nonah, and she tells you she’s been hearing you’re awful, that you hate humans, because you’re willing to consider locking in their Class Two status. And then Gae Neutha calls you up and gives you what-for. How do you react?”
Loona frowned. “Well…I’ve clearly been working with other Representatives, yes?”
“Yes,” Smit said, impassive.
“I talk to them. We meet, we go over the language. We try to weaken the language without killing the bill.”
“Why? Why not kill the bill?”
“Because,” Loona said, “if I wrote that bill, I assume there’s a very good reason for it. And while there may come a point where I can’t give up everything, or where what I’d have to give up is too great…getting some of it through, or getting it through with an annoying change that doesn’t really change the current state of the law — well, better one step forward than none, right?”
Ammer smiled. “We’ve run a couple test polls. Zapat switching to the majority is gonna fry him. If he’d done it earlier, he could finesse it, but the election’s too soon. He can’t deliver anything from his chair’s position, and that? That’s deadly. Add in the mild recession, and you don’t have to do much other than not screw up. Tougher to get through the primary, but if you jump in before word gets out, make a big splash, you’d be in a prohibitive position when he switches.
“Run a series of ads touting yourself as a fresh face — not hard, you’re young for a candidate — and painting Zapat as out of touch, willing to trade principle for power. And get him into a debate. He’s terrible in debates. You’ll clean his clock. Oh, and when you get into the House, I’d align with the Aspire Caucus — they’re liberal, but not too liberal, and they’d leave you room to maneuver.”
Loona looked at the pad. “When can you start?”
That brought a long belly laugh from Smit, who ended by wiping a tear from his eye. “Oh…oh man…she didn’t tell you, did she? Pryvani, that’s just not nice!”
“It’s good advice, I didn’t want to color her perception of it, even a bit, Ammer.”
Loona smiled. “You’re human.”
“Bingo. Born and raised in Atlantis. Did spend a year — human year, not one of your ridiculous, decade-long years — on Archavia, meeting with some folks. It’s a long and boring story, and at some point, I’ll probably bore you with it, because I think you’ve got the right plan of attack, Ms. Armac. I think Pryvani’s right. I think you could do quite well for yourself. If so, I look forward to talking with you.”
“There’s no reason you can’t be my campaign manager,” Loona said. “I know the compensation gets tricky, but I can work it out with Pryvani –”
“It’s not a question of compensation,” Ammer said, sighing. “It’s — well, hell, part of my problem is that deep down, I’m an idealist myself. You might be able to get by with a human campaign manager in this race because, like I said, Zapat is toast as long as you don’t cock it up. But why bother? Get some schmuck to run the show and you’ll be fine.”
“I really don’t want a schmuck,” Loona said. “I want someone who understands me — and who will warn me when I’m getting close to cocking it up. The guys Pryvani’s offered…they’re mercenaries. I don’t want a mercenary.”
Ammer sighed. “Loona,” he said, “you can’t offer me what I want, not without wrecking your chances.”
“I’d put you on staff.”
“Chief of Staff,” Ammer said. “Or nothing.”
“Majordomo,” Loona said.
Ammer looked at her for a moment. “Why majordomo?”
“Majordomo does the scheduling for a Rep. He coordinates the staff. Chief of Staff is the big picture guy, and the go-chat-with-the-press guy. Majordomo almost always is behind-the-scenes. Majordomos are also almost always payoffs to constituents, and my biggest constituency is urban liberals who want to be able to tell their provincial friends that their Imperial Representative has a human on staff! Finally, majordomos can be a bit out there. Pierz has the Ler who self-identifies as an Avartle – and don’t get me wrong, every time I’ve heard Mighty-One-Who-Is-Of-the-People, he seems quite nice. Logran has a Tusolan majordomo, and ze isn’t even a citizen. Why, I believe Sen. Tarsuss has a woman who is completely covered in tattoos as her majordomo — does Tazas still work for you, Pryvani?”
“Of course she does. I would never fire her — she’s a lovely woman, and not just because of the tattoos.”
“So it’s a bit of an eccentric choice, but one I can sell as appealing to my eccentric district, and besides, nobody’s gonna see you; if they do, it will just be some sort of short blurb in Politicus, and only junkies read that anyhow.”
Ammer continued to watch her. “Okay, why not chief of staff?”
Loona smiled. “In a perfect world, Mr. Smit, I’d insist you take that position. You’re good enough for it. Heck, you should be running for this seat, not me. But…well, a human majordomo might be possible. A bit of a risk, but I can finesse it. A human chief of staff…I wish we were there. But we aren’t.”
Ammer clapped his hands together. “Well. I was not expecting this.”
“What?”
“You to be so…I mean, that’s exactly right, Loona. Exactly. If you’d offered me Chief, I would never have taken it. It’s too much. But majordomo….and I could have more influence on the future of humanity as a majordomo for a backbencher than as a councilor in Atlantis, which was the race I was spoiling for next year. Then again…it isn’t fun being officially a pet, Loona, even if you have decent Titans around to make it easier on you. Ask Nonah.”
“I have,” Loona said, “and Dhan and Niall and…well, I’ve had many friends try to explain it. And I’ve tried to understand. But I can’t…not completely. I’m sorry.”
“You’d be a liar if you’d said you could,” he rubbed a hand across his beard. “Of course, I have some failsafes that not all humans have. Hmm. Can I have a few days to think it over?”
Loona leaned in, and studied his face, and smiled. “No. Now or never, Mr. Smit.”
Ammer’s face broke out in a wide grin. “Ms. Armac, that is what I was hoping you’d say. I accept. But…we’re gonna have to do this smart. I can’t be from Avalon. Pryvani, can you help me get registered as an Archavian human pet again?”
“Why again? We still have the paperwork from last time.”
“Brilliant,” Ammer said. “All right, four more conditions. First, I want Pryvani to be listed as my owner.”
“That won’t work,” Pryvani said, before Loona could answer. “It would be like hanging a red flag on your appointment.”
“Yeah, was afraid you’d say that. So who, then?”
Pryvani smiled. “I think if you were purchased by Loona from a friend of mine, it would go down better. Lezah Maris won’t mind.”
Ammer frowned. “Can I trust her?”
Loona fought back the urge to tell him he could; she knew this question was as much for him as for Pryvani.
“I do,” said Pryvani. “Darren did. Niall did, you may recall.”
Ammer smiled at that. “Only reason I agreed to take the call,” he said. “You know, Minister Xanthopolous speaks very, very highly of you, Loona. I wanted to see if you could possibly live up to the hype.”
“And?”
“We’ll see,” Ammer said, grinning. “Okay, I can’t have money, so I want my paycheck given over to the Aenur Foundation, with money for room and board taken out — and room and board is easy, I’ll sleep in my office, it should have space.”
“That one I can agree to,” Loona said. “And it might even get Gae to stop pestering me to increase my donation. But we won’t donate it all. You deserve some of it, and I’ll find a way to get you access to it; there are ways, if you’re creative. All right, third?”
“I’m giving you a signed, undated resignation letter. When the day comes — and it will come — that having a human as majordomo becomes a liability, you must pull it out, stamp a date, and accept it. Immediately.”
“But if –”
“I’m trusting your judgment here,” Ammer said. “Have to. I’m a realist. I’m gonna become a liability if you get up to near-cabinet level, but if you get that far, you won’t need me anymore. And staff always takes the bullet for the elected official — that’s first rule of staff. Frankly, I’d get everyone to give you one of those. Saves time.”
“All right,” Loona said. “Finally?”
“Finally, I want you to be quite aware that this is not for life. I am happy to come for a term or two. But someday, I intend to go back to Avalon, get married, have kids. I’m not a pet, and while I’ll put up with the indignity to help humans…I’m not going to do it forever.”
“I would never ask you to,” Loona said. “You have the same out I do; I will accept your resignation whenever you choose to tender it.”
“Thank you. All right, I’m putting my life in your hands, Ms. Armac. And yours too, Pryvani. Make this worth my while. Wow me.”
Ammer smiled widely, and said, “Aw, who the hell am I kidding? You’ve wowed me, Loona. Just keep wowing me. Don’t make me regret this. Pryvani, I’ll talk to you when you get back to Avalon. Goodbye.”
As the call winked off, Loona blinked. She couldn’t quite believe what she’d just agreed to. She couldn’t quite believe that she was, in fact, going to stand for the House of Representatives.
Most of all, she couldn’t believe that she’d ever doubted that she would. For Ammer Smit was good at his job, and a majordomo’s first job is to ensure that the boss has what she needs.
What Loona needed at that moment was the confidence that she could do this, confidence that she was ready. Some years later, she would wonder if Pryvani and Ammer had planned this out to the letter. Some years after that, she would be certain.
* * *
Two weeks later, Loona was sitting in a newly-rented storefront, which still had shelves where clothing had been displayed. Ammer Smit was standing on one of them, talking animatedly with the senior Titan on Loona’s staff, a young woman named Malya, who had wowed him with her experience working on the recent Tannhauser referendum on increasing school taxes.
“…so I’m relying on you, Ms. Stazkal, to keep me up on the subtle nuances. Politics is similar everywhere, but as the Earth politician Tip O’Neil once said, ‘All politics is local.’ This needs to resonate with the people here.”
“Right,” Malya said, taking notes on her pad. “Well, I think you’ve hit on the main thing – Zapat won’t be able to deliver. But I’m guessing his comeback will be that he’s been in Aspire, and what good has it done the district?”
“Sharp,” Ammer said. “We need to be ready for that. We’re gonna have more staff coming in soon, I want to have one of the interns document Zapat’s record on funding over the years. What I’ve seen hasn’t been particularly impressive.”
“Yeah, he’s vulnerable. He’s supported the majority a few times,” Stazkal said. “I’ll get on that.”
“No, you get on trying to reach out to Pid Artia’s local leaders from five years ago.”
“I can do both.”
“Well, research his voting record on your off time.”
“Yes, Mr. Smit.”
“Boss, we need to work on your speech.”
“I know, Ammer,” Loona said, turning back to her announcement speech. “I feel like there’s something missing.”
“I know there is. You’ve got a great line of attack on Zapat,” Ammer said, scrolling through his own. “Really, you hammer away like Rixie Tam. But I don’t see any reason to vote for you.”
Loona paused. “But…like you said, I identified nine places Zapat’s failed this district.”
“Great. So he’s awful. Why should I vote for you?”
Loona looked down and him. “Oh,” she said.
“Going negative’s easy and important, and you can get people to turn out and vote against the bad person any day. But to really get them to the polls, you need them to want to vote for something.”
Loonah sighed. “So I have to sell myself. I hate that.”
“Get over it. You want to represent 31 million people, including 22 million voters. You’ve got to convince at least 11.1 million that you, Loona Armac, are the representative they deserve. No – the representative they need. Why are you running? Because Pryvani talked you into it? If that’s the only reason, drop out before you get in. It’ll be easier.”
“No,” Loona said. “I think I can do a good job.”
“That’s not enough.”
Loona looked back at Ammer. “I mean, look, I succeeded in saving Darren’s life, got Niall on the faculty at Tannhauser….”
“Too human-centric.”
“Says the human.”
Ammer sighed. “Boss, if I thought you could win just by telling everyone how great humans are, I’d encourage you. If anything, I think that’s a liability. Why you, Loona? What do you want to do if you get to Tuaut?”
“I…I want to make things better.”
“Getting closer. But not quite. Armac, why do you want to run?”
Loona threw up her hands in frustration. “Because the system doesn’t work for the people. It never really has. Look at the way our government’s structured. An appointed, do-nothing Senate that’s only point is to gum up the works. A legislature that’s dominated by conservatives, who still are foot-dragging on issues relating to the rights of non-Titans. Representatives that switch caucuses like they’re seats in a school cafeteria – not because their positions have changed, which would be understandable, but because they think they can get a better appointment.
“I don’t claim to be perfect. But I care about this Empire, and I will work as hard as I can to make it a better place. I know it might not be easy. It wasn’t easy to convince a college that a pet should be a professor – but I did. It wasn’t easy to find a way to save the life of an innocent man, whose only crime was being a human that killed in self-defense – but I did. I have stood up for people who the Empire won’t even recognize as people. And I will stand up for anyone – Titan, Avartle, Dunnermac, Ler, and yes, Human – who needs someone to fight for them. That’s why I’m running.”
Ammer smiled. “Okay. That’s good enough. You’re a professional writer, I’m sure you can take that and work with it.”
Eight Titan days later, Loona did.
“This isn’t about me,” she said to the reporters and volunteers in the room. “If I wanted glory, I would have kept on claiming Nonah’s marvelous books as my own.” She’d been nervous about that line, but it worked – it drew a nice, genuine laugh. “I’m running because I want to serve those of you who need someone to fight for them. The Avartle who is passed over for a promotion because of the way Titans measure lives. The Dunnermac who isn’t given access to safe, clean water. The Ler student, disciplined in class for being too loud. The Titan who is asked to get by on the same rent-and-board credit, while the rent in this district keeps getting more expensive.
“These people need someone to fight for them. Not someone who claims to be from the Aspire caucus, yet votes like he’s from Green and Black. I can’t promise perfection, and I can’t promise the universe, but I promise you, if you elect me to this office I will fight for the people of this district every single day. Thank you, and may fate smile on the Empire.”
The volunteers cheered, and Loona nodded. She looked to her right, where her parents were standing, holding between them Dhan, Nonah, and the kids. Then she looked to her left, where Ammer perched on Malya’s shoulder. She nodded.
“I’ll open the floor for a few questions. Jolel,” she said. She had no doubt the reporters would be hard on her, but at least she knew most of them by name, and knew a great many of them by favorite drink.
“Jolel Horesido, News Station 7 Tannhauser. Ms. Armac, you’ve made a name for yourself as a writer and activist fighting for human rights. Is the push for equal rights for humans going to be the centerpiece of your campaign?”
Loona nodded. “Thank you, Jolel.” Her eyes flicked to Ammer; she couldn’t say this after looking at Nonah. “I believe firmly that humans should be granted the rights they deserve as Class One Sentient Beings. If elected, I hope someday to be able to vote to give them those rights. But you know and I know that we’re not at that point yet.
“So while I support human rights, is that the centerpiece of my campaign? No. But what motivates me to help humans – a belief in fairness and equality for all – that is. We haven’t yet reached a point where we have a fair society. I want to help get us there.”
It hurt, that statement. Because Loona very much wanted to take this opportunity to shout from the rooftops that her friends were people, damn it, and she’d push for equality from the moment she got to Tuaut. But Ammer was right – this wasn’t the time. Not yet.
“Troxel Aiea, Political Wonkery. Ms. Armac, with Rep. Zapat already representing Aspire, do you intend to caucus as a potential member of Forward, or New Empire?”
“I intend to campaign for office as a liberal. Rep. Zapat can call himself a member of Aspire, but his voting record is clear – he’s been more than happy to support the majority during his time there. Now, there are times we all should agree on things. But voting to cut funding to colleges, like he did in 2101? That’s not what a liberal does.”
There were a few more questions and answers, before Loona thanked everyone and retired to the space behind the faux wall in the front of headquarters, where the desks were crammed, along with some spare shelves.
“Nice job, Boss! Note-perfect on the human thing,” Ammer said, as Malya and he reached the back.
“The ‘human thing?’” Nonah asked, indignantly. “Is that what they call basic rights on Avalon?”
“Now, Nonah,” Ammer called; he had to admit, this wasn’t an easy conversation to have perched on one staffer’s shoulder, while looking down to the woman and her daughter in the hands of his candidate’s dad.
“Don’t ‘Now, Nonah’ me,” she huffed. “I don’t expect Loona to base her whole campaign around us, but she could push a bit harder than ‘I support it, but I won’t do anything.’”
“That’s not what she said, mom.”
“Lessy, you don’t understand,” Nonah said.
“What, like all us humans don’t understand things? Aunt Loona said she thinks we’re equal, but she needs more Titans to agree with her. Which is what Niall said to dad when I was playing with Sorcha. ‘Loona running is nice, but it can’t be just her,’” Lessy said, delivering the last in a rather impressive Irish brogue.
“Your daughter is how old?”
“Four Titan years, but her father and I were life-extended, so….”
“Yeah, so, like, one and a half,” Ammer said; he skipped the next round of math that would have made her the equivalent of an eight-year-old on Earth. He laughed. “Funny thing is, I didn’t get life-extended ‘til adulthood. She’s actually a bit older than me. Anyhow, kid, when you grow up…if you want to run for office on Avalon, you give me a call.”
“Can Sorcha come, too?”
“Sure. You two friends?”
“Best friends,” Lessy said.
“Dangerously so,” Nonah added; she was beaming with pride, though. “All right, maybe I’m just sensitive.”
“No, you’re not,” Loona said, reaching out her hand, and taking her friend from her father. “It stinks. But…if I make humans the reason I’m running, I lose. And that doesn’t help you.”
Nonah sighed. “All right, apology accepted in perpetuity. It was a nice speech,” she said.
“Coming from you?” Loona said, “That’s as good as it gets.”
#Nitestarr: Chihuahuas are barky little vermin. Nothing more; nothing less. 😉
I missed this part;
“Pierz has the Ler who self-identifies as an Avartle”……
Soo we have an alligator who thinks he (she?) is a chihuahua………nice
Speaking of lizards the more I think of it, the more Douglas Adams was right…we shouldn’t run anything, we should let the lizards do. They would do a better job too…I would definitely vote for that insurance gecko…
Avartles are more like lemurs, going by the descriptions of Engine-Fixer in Exile, Pandemic, and The Continuing Adventures.
I know but chihuahua sounds better….. the problem is that I can’t tell if there’re just a really furry dog or a chipmunk with an attitude..
“Speaking of lizards the more I think of it, the more Douglas Adams was right…we shouldn’t run anything, we should let the lizards do. They would do a better job too…I would definitely vote for that insurance gecko…”
If you’re talking about Hitchhiker’s Guide, that was either Mice or Dolphins, depending on which you’re referring to
Yes and It was lizards…
https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/162557-it-comes-from-a-very-ancient-democracy-you-see-you
and
https://geoffmead.wordpress.com/tag/hitchhikers-guide-to-the-galaxy/
I AM however having second thoughts on this lizard issue…….
Who’s Dhan? 😕
He popped up at the very end of Physics initially he and Noona hooked up. He also had a cameo in Pandemic. He hasn’t gotten a lot of focus yet.
Nonah’s baby-daddy/husband.
I like the direction of the story, but could you please not use real world political terms? Not only is it distracting, it’s also a little insulting.
I will say that I can’t tell if you’re a liberal who’s allowing your personal biases to color your perception of conservatives, a conservative that’s painting a caricature of liberals, or a moderate/libertarian poking a finger in the eye of both sides. Nonetheless, I find the use of modern political labels very distracting to the story. I see enough politics in day to day life, i don’t want to be reminded of it when i read escapist literature.
I would like to clarify that I personally am not a liberal. I’m a weird, fucked up mix between centre right economics, socialism and libertarianism.
D.X has a lot of political experience. I asked him to write Loona as a sensible liberal as her parents were die hard hippies. She is not a hippy but she’s pretty liberal.
Politics was bound to seep into the story at some point. The trick is getting the balance. This story will be heavy on politics, as it is a political story. But it will also give nice snap shots of life down the line from the beginning of the series. Judge the book by the end, not the first two chapters 😛
For the record, being right or left doesn’t make you bad person. Being a bad person does.
I agree about one thing: using real world terms is distracting, and it would be much more immersive to develop terms that are appropriate given the history and culture of the Empire. This is something I expect DX would be able to do well.
So what I’m getting is that this story is just a vehicle for the author’s political views. There are assumptions and logic holes that one could drive a 18 wheeler through. Quite unfortunate..
Heh I’m kind of curious why you feel that way since this is the first pure negative review you’ve given. I mean technically all the stories are vehicles for the authors particular fetish and can get pretty nonsensical to fulfill them. I didn’t notice anything too offensive about the political talk in this chapter and Titans are aliens so they may do things differently.
There was nothing really offensive in this chapter. I feel that the author’s political point of view has become a character in the story. Its annoying and detracts from the story. Its also very unoriginal. I understand the political underpinnings of this verse is important to the storyline but it shouldn’t become the focus of the story.
Not sure what you mean by this, it’s pretty clear this was going to be a political story from the start. So it’s pretty much impossible not to focus on it.
Yes I know its a political story or a story concerning a well known protagonist from an earlier story and her venture into the political area of Titan society. My main complaint is that the author’s (personal) views are assumed to be an alien’s view (political). This is supposed to be a work of fiction and to me it almost appears to be a thinly disguised advertisement for a political (current, real) viewpoint. To me that is laziness and insulting to the reader (well to me at least).
That might seem harsh but I am sooo fucking sick of what passes for entertainment today. Movies, TV shows, Infotainment, News (ha ha ah hah ha..won’t go there…) etc. With a distinct political bias. And it is soo obvious. I don’t mind having a ‘message’ in the medium. But don’t fuckin hit me over the head with a ball peen hammer with that ‘message’ insinuating that I need to be ‘educated’
______
That being said I still enjoyed the story and the characters…despite the other problems with it… 🙂
~The Grinch~
I don’t think DX was trying to beat us over the head with his political views. I mean most of the political stuff in Titan is going to be liberal by default due to the protagonists wanting equal rights for humans.
I resent that. My political polemics are more half-assed than lazy. 😛
In all seriousness, I hope that you’ll stick with this; this isn’t a story about what jerks conservatives are, at least not exclusively. Both sides have plenty of jerks. (After all, most of the jerk hired guns Loona was offered by Pryvani? Liberals.)
For the record I’m neither conservative or liberal. Classical liberal? ….I lean toward Libertarianism..
Ahhhh sooo politics (or one version of it) is a fetish for some….
Yes…that makes sense. Thanks Kaz
>.>
To you and to TheKnowing : well, it’s pretty transparent the authors are quite liberal in their political views, that’s nothing new if you paid attention. While I don’t share many of those views, I don’t mind seeing them in a story as long as that story is credible and not pure wishful thinking. On that front, I have nothing bad to say about the series so far.
If you wanna be a liberal fiction, that’s fine, be, say, The West Wing; don’t be one of those ridiculous TV shows that are just big budget liberal fanfiction. To stay on the political theme, last show like that I can think of that made it to my country (France) was Commander in Chief with Geena Davis as the president. What I remember from it was Democrat President Geena Davis making Republican Speaker Donald Sutherland (who are fierce political enemies) freaking cry in the middle of the Oval Office about how he used to be so racist ant that’s not who he is anymore. I think that was like episode 2.
/rolleyes
But Campaign seems on the right track : while the main protagonists are liberal, they stay real. Both Loona and even more so Ammer are on the No Bullshit wagon when it comes to the fight for Humans right. They know they can’t do it all in one go and that they need to be careful and cunning. I like that.
Frankly, I’m much more worried about Contact as what little we know about it does sound like liberal wishful thinking :
– the transgender US president ? With religion so strong in the country and in the growing ethnicities (most notably latinos) ?
– the Short War ? Suddenly all the countries get scared into giving hands and singing Kumbaya because of a near catastrophic military skirmish ? Missile crisis anyone ? “The Last of the Last” anyone ? (what they called World War I)
– and they do that through the UN ? With every country having a more or less equal say like a sitting Assembly in a democracy ?
I’m sorry but… /rolleyes
And the very fact that the wikia is so well detailed heavily implies that political nonsense (to me anyway) will have a very important part to play in Contact. I’m hoping I’m wrong.
I think you’re vastly underestimating what can be achieved in 100 years. While I think some things are implausible at best, I’m not going to stress over it, like I’m not going to stress over the politics in this story. It’s like people complaining about politics in Star Wars or Star Trek when it’s equally bullshit.
What can be achieved ? I apologize if I’m wrong but you seem to assume that History is linear, that eventually, it will always go in the sense of “progress”; that if we’re not there, we’re merely not there “yet”.
That’s a very liberal (and before that, communist) conception of History.
It is simply not true.
Example : if we were to compare the level of freedom of speech in many muslim countries today and what that level was centuries ago, at the peak of the Arab expansion, which one would be the most liberal ? Right.
History is NOT a line – straight or otherwise – towards progress.
What bothers me in this snapshot of Contact is its foundations are set on behaviors I believe are contrary to human nature : the UN thing is UNbelievable to me. Humans do not share power willingly; we do everything we can to gain it, to keep it, to make it grow. And it is through the balance of powers that we go forward, create equal footing alliances, etc.
That view might make me a cynical but that’s how I see things.
13TH Amendment ratified 1865, first US African American elected president 2008. 143 years. A bit more than a century but then again Transgender people aren’t slaves and already have laws on the books protecting them.
Woman’s suffrage in the UK formerly passed (for women over 30) in 1918. They had a female Prime Minister (and a conservative one at that) in 1979 so about 61 years.
In United States Gay Marriage is trending toward full legal acceptance when gay sex was still illegal nationwide less than 50 years ago.
Your right progress is never a guarantee, but at the same time that doesn’t mean progress doesn’t happen. A lot can happen in a hundred years, the key word being can, there’s just no promise it will.
More to the point considering this is a fiction that requires us to believe in giant aliens that look exactly like us not only exist, but have developed a pretty similar culture to us, and have a station on the moon of Titan, that the United States is accepting of Transgender political office in 120 years or so isn’t the biggest suspension of disbelief. :p
It is somewhat realistic IMO. A 130 + years for this Utopia to occur is optimistic. Took a look at the current headlines? (well not the ones here,…. our ‘news’ is carefully filtered pablum designed for the masses) It ain’t pretty. Basic human nature does not change that quickly. Gains that are made can be reverted – in short time. In some cases it already is..Hopeful wishful thinking does not change this reality.
This doesn’t mean that I think we are doomed as a species but I am very sceptical..The UN is a complete joke and should be scrapped completely..They are causing some of the problems..
I like how you call it a Utopia when we only got a snap shot at how Earth is in the future. Ya’ll assuming way too much. I doubt Earth is going to have a united front on what to do with.the Titans and how they feel about pet humans and Avalon.
Agreed with Kazuma with the very fact that there are still nations implies the potential for discord and power plays. It’s impossible to grasp the scope of the world in one sentence.
I’ll defend my future history thus: The Short War was the capstone on a century and a half of war, that killed half a billion people, on top of another half a billion who died due to a combination of war and environmental catastrophe, and it almost resulted in the apocalypse. At some point, people on Earth would (and will) be confronted with a choice of whether to keep fighting or work together. I’ll freely admit, our history suggests that we’ll choose the former more often than not, but every so often we surprise ourselves.
So Lessy ages twice as fast as a normal titan and in human years she is 26 years old but physically and mentally she is 8 years old?
I didn’t consider the life extension treatment causing human kids to take decades to grow up. I don’t know why this makes me further divided on the whole thing. It seems like the life extension treatment will just turn humans into tiny titans.
Thanks for mentioning it, I had missed that bit of information.
If that’s true, then I hope the life-extension treatment is a rare thing (Ammer seems to imply it’s common though, at least on Avalon) because if it’s wide-spread, that means the one advantage Humans have over Titans – maturing and learning very fast – would be virtually destroyed.
And it’s not like Humanity’s chances are all that good to begin with…
Well, Earth is “spared” this treatment for now, at least until Contact, but after that, if offered, who wouldn’t want to have their life vastly expanded ? And then, as always, Titans meddling, while full of good intentions, would end up screwing Humans over. Again.
While it’s clear it’s taken her more time to physically develop it’s hard to say how it effects someone mentally. Would be weird, and kind of awesome, if mentally humans developed at the same rate, or even if it slightly slower, despite their physical age.
She is 26 Earth years old but Nonah implies she’s not a teenager yet, and I don’t think she meant just her physical age, I think she meant mentally too.
So Lessy may be a smart kid, she’s still a kid. Even if she’s a genius on say, science things (and I don’t think she is), emotional maturity is half the intelligence of a person. And it is implied that she is a child, at least emotionally (and physically of course).
So, no, pretty sure it is as it seems : just plain Titan-scale aging…
Well I don’t think you need to worry about earth humans being effected by the LE treatment. Humanity isn’t ready for people living well over 200 years and children taking nearly 50 years to reach puberty. That said, there is still a lot of unknowns surrounding the treatment so while I feel conflicted about it I’m not going to make any assumptions yet.
Oh this has the potential to become my favorite story, I know some people aren’t into it but I do love political wheeling’s and dealings.
One thing I love about the titan verse is that with each human that appears that’s not a pet it almost begs for a spin off. One chapter with Ammer and I want know more! A man who voluntarily leaves Avalon where he has full rights, to Archavia? So compelled by the human rights movement he’s willing to do it again?!
That would be enough by itself but he was sharp, clever and a good personality pairing with Loona.
Oh and Loona despite all the curveballs Pryvani threw at her really handled herself well. She’s really developed into a razor sharp character.
Also so many other little tidbits like where is Avalon technologically now it’s only been about 80 years but then Ammer mentions life extension. Then there are the mentions of Gae and that Lezah Maris is a ‘friend’ of Pryvani. Gah! There are so many little teases!
Great chapter can’t wait till the next one.
And TETH is somehow still around.
We’ll need to see how Nomad ends before we even know what state they’re left in. I love the politics of this, should set up Contact and Hybrid really nicely.
I didn’t think I’d enjoy a politically focused GTS story but I’m really enjoying myself with this one. Ammer is an interesting character, very different from all the rest which is refreshing. Now if I remember that image you showed, Ammer has a Titan partner named Innanae. I guess they haven’t met yet in this current time.
More glimpses into the future with this chapter. It seems the life extension treatment is becoming wide spread on Atlantis. I wonder how that is effecting their development and how far Atlantis has come in 80+ human years.
Life extension might be becoming widespread, but so far we’ve seen Nonah and Dhan, and by genetic reproduction, their children. Ammer also apparently. I didn’t get the idea tho that the general population was life-extended or that they weren’t. But so far, the only cases I know of, are people who somehow manage to have a direct relationship with Pryvani.
Ugh, my braaaainnnss! Too many multi-syllable words! XD
Anyway, I really like the characters in this story but I’m hoping we get breaks from the heavy political stuff. I know people are probably going to say that having “rest” chapters is a waste of time but I think they help balance things out. I’ll say that so far I’m really fond of Ammer! He seems like a great human that can show Titans that humans can hold intelligent discussions, no problem….He’s kind of pompous though, but that comes with the territory XP.
Good chapter overall!
To be honest I kind of want the other stories to cut the fat so we can get to contact faster >.>
I’m the opposite. I feel like everyone is in too much of a rush to get to the end.
Lol who said Contact and Hybrid would be the end?
I”m probably biased against rest chapters because while you liked the R and A chapters in Pandemic, I didn’t, but I don’t want open that bee hive again. I like Campaigns snappy flow and I’d hate for it to be broken up.
I agree with you on “rest” chapters. I think the reason I enjoyed Pandemic so much was because of the Rixie and Alex side story that it had integrated. Though that might be because they’re my favorite characters.
Lessy’s a precocious little scamp, isn’t she?
You have no idea.